Members of British Parliament are forbidden from resigning.
To circumvent this, they get themselves appointed to a "paid office under the Crown", which disqualifies them as an MP. There are two nominally paid offices kept for this purpose, one of which is Steward or Bailiff of Her Majesty's Three Chiltern Hundreds of Stoke, Desborough and Burnham in the county of Buckingham. Leaving parliament voluntarily is therefore sometimes called Taking The Chiltern Hundreds .

What I find so fantastic about this 350 year old hack is that though it could easily be fixed with legislation, British politicians prefer to muddle along with the workaround, elevating it to not just a tradition but a minor institution complete with idiomatic fixtures.

Wow guys. Just wow. Good luck with that House of Lords reform.
Cam Riley: South Sea Republic. Freedom, liberty, equity and an Australian Republic.

Comments

  • cam . # .
    To take a software analogy: of I think of the British implementation of Westminster as a group of teenage kids having written spaghetti code in VB many years ago, and now it has many important transactions that it must perform, that it cant be updated and any change to the code is approached with fear for the whole system failing.

    I dont understand why Australia seeks to establish the British political heritage. We have innovated far past Britain\'s achievements in political science. Even our states can look back at London and laugh at their pre-industrial structures and electoral technologies.

    It is also ironic that we follow British politics and American foriegn policy, when the Americans were the great political scientists and the British Empire had better foriegn policy than the current American manner of power politics, which they play, and play hard.

    I guess Britain will require a political leader that can say, lets rewrite it in python! But consensus will probably lead it to being written in perl or lisp.

    cam
  • avocadia . # .
    Python?: Bah! Too bureacratic with all its white spacing. \'sides, Ruby (almost) does multiple inheritance.
  • adam . # .
    So?: Python\'s been almost doing multiple inheritance for years :)
  • adam . # .
    Caveat: That is of course the sentiment that prompted me to post. But I think it\'s worthwhile noting that in this case the mechanism has been refactored over time until it is nearly equivalent to a resignation process written from scratch, as it were. Eg on the wikipedia page it described an incident where 15 Ulster Unionist MPs resigned at once. To deal with the resource limitation of only two crown appointments they queued the MPs so technically each held the position for an hour or so.

    It does have rather a silly name though.
  • cam . # .
    Holding the position: for an hour or so? Kind of requires a baton to formalise the process, they could hand it on over a 400m section of pavement.

    Obviously they have dealt with a niche condition in their system in a manner that works. But often work-arounds like that end up being absurd and speaks to deeper flaws in the system.

    Is it a case of conservatism or simply not wanting to muck with it?

    cam
  • adam . # .
    Small-c conservatism: I\'d say it\'s small-c conservatism, ie not wanting to muck with it.
  • avocadia . # .
    Whitespace!: froth
  • cam . # .
    Similar experience to Australia: convention is only legislated over once someone breaks it, and it leaves a lasting scar - like the dismissal when Lewis and Bjelke-Peterson went against convention and appointed Senators that were not from the party that vacated the Senate.

    This produced a referendum question two years later; Senate Casual Vacancies . It does put parties in the constitution;

    Where a vacancy has at any time occurred in the place of a senator chosen by the people of a State and, at the time when he was so chosen, he was publicly recognised by a particular political party as being an endorsed candidate, a person chosen or appointed under this section in consequence of that vacancy, or in consequence of that vacancy and a subsequent vacancy or vacancies, shall, unless there is no member of that party available to be chosen or appointed, be a member of that party.

    Where;

      (a) in accordance with the last preceding paragraph, a member of a particular political party is chosen or appointed to hold the place of a senator whose place had become vacant; and

      (b) before taking his seat he cease to be a member of that party (otherwise than by reason of the party having ceased to exist),

    Is it preferable to have former members rotate through a faux position requiring retirement, or to have political parties entrenched in the constitution in order to avoid the race condition that is the reserve powers in the Australian constitution?

    cam
  • cam . # .
    A python developer commenting on java: \"I never understood why java developers liked typing so much?\"

    I think notepad that comes with windows can handle python indenting. I think that is its default setting.

    cam