I suspect there is a visibility aspect to it as well. It is like the "what have the Romans ever done for us, other than ..." style of Monty Python joke. Then again the Roman system for the voting citizen was highly social democratic, grain was given out without cost, Egypt was important for that reason alone and a reason why the emperor Augustine kept it as his private pro-consulship. The Aedile position was also one of public works, building aqueducts, etc. The Greeks had a word for public works too, can't recall what it was now, but basically the wealthy classes had to give money over to works in order to keep social stability.
I recall the Islamic group that installed itself in Somalia taking a similar tack to Hamas and Hezbollah by establishing their governing legitimacy with social services. They got run out of town by violence, but Islam and its internal organization makes it a quick candidate to bring order and services to chaotic regions that suffer from poor or a lack of governance.
'Sworn to no party, and of no sect am I.' Frederick Vosper's republican motto.
Comments